SCREENING ·SOUTH DAKOTA · 3 MIN READ

Application Fees in South Dakota: Common Mistakes Landlords Make

By Curt Sloan · October 30, 2026

Application Fees in South Dakota: Common Mistakes Landlords Make

Application Fees in South Dakota: Common Mistakes Landlords Make

South Dakota has no statutory cap on rental application fees. The South Dakota Attorney General Consumer Protection division and state courts evaluate fee practices under general consumer protection principles and common law fairness standards. While you have flexibility in setting your screening costs, landlords across the state make four recurring mistakes that create liability and tenant friction.

Mistake One: Charging Fees Without Written Disclosure

The most common error is accepting application money without a written statement of what the fee covers. You must tell applicants in writing whether the fee pays for credit checks, criminal background reports, eviction history searches, or administrative time. Without this clarity, applicants in Sioux Falls and Rapid City have successfully disputed charges as arbitrary or excessive in small claims court.

Best practice is a one page disclosure that lists each screening component and its cost. If you charge $50 for a combined credit and criminal check that costs you $32, document the $18 administrative handling. Courts respect transparency.

Mistake Two: Keeping Fees When You Never Run Screening

South Dakota law does not require refunds for application fees, but keeping money when you perform no actual screening creates a strong fairness argument against you. If an applicant withdraws before you pull reports or you fill the unit with another tenant first, retaining the full fee looks punitive.

Document every screening action you take with timestamps. If you decide not to proceed with an application, refund the portion tied to reports you never ordered. This practice reduces disputes and builds goodwill in competitive rental markets like Brookings near South Dakota State University.

Mistake Three: Recycling Reports Across Multiple Properties

Some landlords pull one background check and apply it to multiple units the same person inquires about, charging separate fees each time. This practice invites claims of unjust enrichment. If you own three properties and the applicant expresses interest in all three, charge one fee and apply the same screening results across your portfolio.

The South Dakota Attorney General Consumer Protection office has authority to investigate deceptive trade practices. Charging multiple fees for a single report can trigger scrutiny under consumer fairness review.

Mistake Four: No Written Policy on Refunds or Reapplication

Without a written policy, you create inconsistent treatment. One applicant gets a partial refund, another does not, and you face a discrimination claim. Even though South Dakota does not mandate refund rules by statute, your internal policy must apply uniformly.

Draft a standard procedure. If someone reapplies within 90 days, will you waive the second fee or offer a discount? If you deny an application, do you refund any portion? Put it in writing and apply it every time.

What South Dakota Landlords Should Do Next

Create a written application fee disclosure form that lists each screening component and its cost. Track every screening action with vendor receipts and timestamps. Establish a refund policy that addresses withdrawn applications and multiple property inquiries. Train anyone who accepts applications to follow your written procedures without deviation.

Consult an attorney for your specific situation if you manage properties across multiple South Dakota counties or handle high volume student housing near universities.

Streamline Application Screening with Manorway Rentals

Manorway Rentals gives you AI assisted tools to document every application decision, generate consistent fee disclosures, and track screening expenses in real time. You avoid the common mistakes that create liability while keeping your process fast and transparent. Explore how Manorway helps South Dakota landlords manage applications at manorway.com.

Get the weekly digest

One statute update, one practical tactic, one landlord story. Thursdays. Free.

Subscribe
See how it works